Must DC circuit breakers always be bipolar?

09/02/2025

For a 24V switch-mode power supply branch, I used a single-pole DC circuit breaker, with the negative pole subjected to equipotential bonding (previously, I even directly used AC breakers as substitutes—the main difference being arc-extinguishing performance, but how significant can the arc be in a few-amp low-current short circuit?).

During a design review, an expert stated that DC circuit breakers must be bipolar, arguing that DC has positive and negative poles, unlike AC!

I'm puzzled—where is this regulation specified? Later, I wondered, why would manufacturers even produce single-pole versions? What is the rationale for requiring switching of the negative pole as well? According to available information, if a DC breaker is connected in reverse, the primary impact should only be on arc-extinguishing performance. Also, when I mentioned that the negative pole is equipotentially bonded, another expert claimed that "equipotential" doesn't apply to DC systems—only to AC. Is that true? It's strange—many sensors clearly mark their power supply negative terminal with the "GND" symbol.

For the incoming PE (protective earth) wire in the electrical cabinet, I directly used the PE green-yellow terminal on the mounting rail, but was told it's not acceptable and must be connected to a dedicated grounding busbar. It's hard to question the experts we've invited, especially those from the maritime field—marine applications are quite special, right?

image.png

User A's View:
Probably just being overly cautious. DC arc extinction differs from AC, but for low-voltage circuits, it might not be such a big concern. In my opinion, if it's not a critical application, a single-pole breaker, as long as it's reliable and won't cause contact welding, should be acceptable. Marine electrical systems primarily emphasize fire and safety. So safety must be prioritized.

User B's View:
In special cases, such requirements may be stricter. The intent is likely to ensure both poles are disconnected. If 0V is grounded, there could be risks of high-voltage intrusion, causing problems.

User C's View:
I relate to the point about the incoming PE wire. I directly used the PE terminal on the rail, but was told it's not allowed and must go to a grounding busbar. I understand this—it's a code requirement to ensure reliable and safe grounding.

User D's View:
Don't blindly follow outdated standards. I believe that any conductor carrying current or voltage should be controllable and interruptible. Standards from decades ago aren't necessarily safe today. Technology advances, and so should some standards.

User E's View:
For specified DC loads, polarity (+/-) is always clearly marked—reversing connections can lead to serious consequences. I'm not sure how exactly equipotential bonding is implemented, but I once modified an American machine where they kept saying the PLC wasn't sending signals, causing disputes and even involving the equipment department head. He simply used a multimeter—one probe on the chassis, one on the terminal—and concluded to "check the downstream side" (it turned out the software had disabled it). The issue was resolved by implementing equipotential bonding. Since you're dealing with marine applications, just follow the experts' recommendations.

User F's View:
If you use a bipolar breaker, it implies the negative terminal is not grounded—i.e., an isolated system. In such cases, a positive-to-ground short won't immediately cause a trip. The method of grounding the negative pole and using equipotential bonding isn't suitable for all situations. For equipment that can stop immediately, this method can help locate fault points and resolve issues. However, it's inappropriate for applications like medical or lifting equipment. Also, experts aren't omnipotent—they're only deeply familiar with certain areas. If you specialize deeply in a field, you can become an expert too.

If you have other suggestions or insights, feel free to share and discuss!

As an expert in the application and trends of electrical equipment, I have a profound mastery of knowledge in circuits, power electronics, etc. I possess a comprehensive set of abilities including equipment design, fault diagnosis, and project management. I can precisely grasp the industry's pulse and lead the development of the electrical field.

A hybrid DC circuit breaker
A hybrid DC circuit breaker
Most DC molded-case circuit breakers use natural air arc extinction, and there are typically two arc extinguishing methods: one is conventional opening and closing, where the contacts axially stretch the arc, while the conductive circuit generates a magnetic field that bends and elongates the arc, pulling it lengthwise perpendicular to the arc axis. This not only increases the arc length but also induces lateral motion, enabling air cooling to achieve arc extinction.The other method involves the
09/02/2025
Working Principle and Arc Extinction Mechanism of Magnetic Blowout Device in DC Circuit Breakers
Working Principle and Arc Extinction Mechanism of Magnetic Blowout Device in DC Circuit Breakers
The arc extinguishing system of a DC circuit breaker is crucial for the safe operation of equipment, as the arc generated during current interruption can damage contacts and compromise insulation.In AC systems, the current naturally passes through zero twice per cycle, and AC circuit breakers take full advantage of these zero-crossing points to extinguish the arc.However, DC systems lack natural current zero crossings, making arc extinction significantly more difficult for DC circuit breakers. T
09/02/2025
Key Technologies of Low-Voltage DC Solid-State Circuit Breakers
Key Technologies of Low-Voltage DC Solid-State Circuit Breakers
1 Technical Challenges1.1Stability of Device ParallelingIn practical applications, the current-carrying capacity of a single power electronic device is relatively limited. To meet high-current requirements, multiple devices are often connected in parallel. However, parameter variations between devices—such as slight differences in on-resistance and threshold voltage—can cause uneven current distribution during parallel operation. During switching transients, parasitic inductance and capacitance
09/02/2025
 Can AC and DC circuit breakers be used interchangeably?
Can AC and DC circuit breakers be used interchangeably?
First of all, it must be clarified: AC circuit breakers must not be used to replace DC circuit breakers in DC circuits!Due to differences in arc generation and extinction processes between AC and DC, AC and DC circuit breakers with the same rated values do not have identical capabilities when interrupting DC power. Using AC circuit breakers in place of DC ones, or mixing AC and DC breakers, is one of the main causes of protection miscoordination and unintended upstream tripping.Circuit breakers
09/02/2025
Inquiry
Download
IEE-Business is dedicated to serving the personnel in the global power industry.
Join IEE-Business, not only can you discover power equipment and power knowledge, but also canhnd like - minded friends!