• Product
  • Suppliers
  • Manufacturers
  • Solutions
  • Free tools
  • Knowledges
  • Experts
  • Communities
Search


Pure air vs SF6 switchgear

Rockwill
Field: Manufacturing
10Year<
China

iee-business

Is "pure air" insulation finally a credible replacement for SF6 in medium-voltage switchgear? We break it down on the metrics that matter.

"Pure air" is the marketing name for a new generation of SF6-free insulation systems that use conditioned, dry, compressed air — sometimes at higher pressure, sometimes mixed with small amounts of climate-friendly gases — to replace sulfur hexafluoride inside the sealed tank. As utilities and industrial sites move away from SF6, the question is no longer whether to go SF6-free, but which technology delivers the same performance without the trade-offs.

The short answer

For 12–24kV distribution and ring-main applications, pure air switchgear is a credible, direct SF6 replacement: zero GWP, sealed vacuum interruption, comparable safety and familiar installation. It only gives way to gas-insulated or solid-insulated designs where extreme compactness at higher voltage is the single priority.

Side-by-side comparison

Pure air switchgear vs SF6 switchgear
Criterion Pure air switchgear SF6 switchgear
Insulation medium Conditioned dry compressed air Sulfur hexafluoride (SF6)
Global warming potential Zero ≈ 23,500 × CO2
Arc interruption Sealed vacuum interrupter SF6 blast / vacuum (hybrid)
Voltage class 12–24kV (extending to 36kV) 12kV and above, incl. compact GIS
Regulatory outlook Aligned with F-gas phase-down Restricted; reporting & recovery costs
Leakage risk Harmless air; nothing to recover Heavy gas, asphyxiation & climate risk
Maintenance Pressure monitor, sealed vacuum Gas-density checks and top-ups
End of life Standard recycling Specialized gas recovery & disposal

1. What "pure air" actually is

Unlike early SF6-free designs that simply vented ordinary air, pure-air systems condition the air — drying it strictly, controlling humidity, and often sealing it in a welded tank at mild positive pressure. Because air alone has lower dielectric strength than SF6 at the same pressure, modern designs combine optimized internal shielding, compact electrode geometry and vacuum interruption to reach the required ratings. The result is insulation that needs no fluorinated gas at all.

2. Performance and reliability

A common worry is whether pure air can hold off 12–24kV and clear fault currents as well as SF6. In practice, the fault-current interruption is handled by vacuum interrupters — a technology with decades of proven service — while the pure-air medium handles steady-state insulation. Units meet IEC 62271 class ratings (typically 20kA/3s at 12–24kV), so there is no reliability gap for distribution applications.

3. Footprint and retrofits

iee-business

Pure-air RMUs and switchgear are designed to fit the same or similar cubicle envelopes as conventional SF6 units, which is a major advantage when replacing gear in existing substations with limited space. They are not quite as dense as high-voltage GIS, but they avoid the retrofitting cost of changing switchroom dimensions.

4. Safety, regulation and total cost

Because the medium is breathable air, there is no asphyxiation hazard in cable pits and basements, and no specialized gas-handling on site. Over the asset life, pure air removes three hidden costs SF6 owners keep paying: periodic gas-density monitoring and top-ups, F-gas reporting, and end-of-life gas recovery. For new specifications, the total cost of ownership is typically lower.

Bottom line: specify pure air for new 12–24kV ring main units, secondary substations and any project under ESG or F-gas pressure. Keep SF6 only where a space-constrained GIS application truly demands it.

Pure air products from ROCKWILL

We build SF6-free ring main units insulated with pure/dry air, and supply them to distributors and EPCs as a manufacturer under your brand. For the broader medium-voltage panel view, see our dry air switchgear range, and read the companion piece on dry air vs SF6 switchgear.

Specifying pure air switchgear?

Send us your one-line diagram and ratings. We will return a configuration, datasheet and export quote within one working day.

Give a tip and encourage the author!

Comments

Share your question or perspective
WhatsApp
Send inquiry
+86
Click to upload file
Download
Get the IEE Business Application
Use the IEE-Business app to find equipment, obtain solutions, connect with experts, and participate in industry collaboration anytime, anywhere—fully supporting the development of your power projects and business.
Login
or continue with
New here?
Register